Wednesday, November 30, 2016

Amherst Police Department's Notes

Amherst PD's release of notes filed by detectives - notes pertaining to the Petrit Vasi hit-and-run - stops on the afternoon Maura Murray is believed to have disappeared.

Amherst PD was, of course, not required by state public records law to release any other notes about the Vasi case if their release might compromise further investigation. In other words, the records released by Amherst PD do not necessarily represent the entire case file, and therefore do not provide a full picture of the Vasi investigation.

With that in mind, however...

It seems safe to assume that on Monday night, 09 February 2004, Haverhill police contacted UMass police in order to discover in whose name the Saturn's UMass parking sticker was issued.

And safe to assume UMass police, in turn, contacted Amherst police about the Saturn. After all, UMass police knew about the Vasi hit. And about Maura's Corolla crash (because UMass, in addition to Hadley, had responded).

In fact, it seems likely Maura was not arrested for OUI at the scene of the Corolla crash because a UMass cop had intervened on her behalf; which must have been learned by Amherst PD when UMass police told Amherst police about the Saturn's NH location.

Did Amherst police just ignore the fact that a UMass student's car, a car with unexplained body damage, was found mysteriously abandoned in NH a few days after Vasi was hit? Presumably not. No surprise then that there's not a single note in the released portion of the Vasi case file about this.

There's also no note in the released file about police examination of the Corolla. If the Corolla crash was such an isolated, irrelevant event, why did police examine the Corolla so closely after learning that the Saturn was found in NH? The only connection is that both vehicles appeared to have been driven by the same person, Maura Murray, a fact initially known only to UMass police.

On a side note, one might wonder why Lt. John Scarinza (NHSP) was baffled by the fact that Maura was not arrested as a result of her having crashed the Corolla in Hadley. Wasn't he told why?

If Amherst police were investigating the Vasi case, which they were, then why look at the Corolla as part of that investigation? The leading explanation, one would think, is that the Saturn was customarily driven by the same person who had crashed the Corolla, Maura. (Both cars were registered to Maura's father.) If there had been no news about the Saturn from NH, would there still have been as strong a reason, or any reason at all, to examine the Corolla?

In other words, police, investigating the Vasi hit, would not have taken any interest in the Corolla if they had not first been interested in Maura as a possible suspect in the Vasi hit - interested because the Saturn, with a UMass parking sticker, was found in NH, found with body damage that had not been sustained nearby, driven there by a driver who had apparently fled.

Since the Corolla damage had already been accounted for by Hadley police as ordinary operator "inattention," the only reason it was so closely examined after the Saturn was found must have been due to police interest in Maura as the person who had struck Vasi - interest inspired by the Saturn's discovery.

So... The Vasi investigation notes - that is, the notes that were released - end at mid-afternoon on Monday. And then Maura disappears. And then the Saturn is found a few hours later in NH.

And that's it? Amherst detectives just stopped investigating the Vasi hit right around the time Maura apparently left UMass? They stopped investigating right after a UMass student's car, with unexplained body damage, was found mysteriously abandoned in NH? While Vasi lay in a coma, on the verge of death?

Seems there are a lot of things police didn't do after the Saturn was found. But one thing police did do was look closely at the Corolla. 

How odd that my backyard was lightly vandalized just hours after my having written on Topix in 2008 about this very same police interest in the Corolla. I mean, who would do such a thing? Not LE, right?






Although this narrative was filed on Tuesday, 10 FEB, the interview itself took place the day before.

Monday, November 28, 2016

Petrit Vasi: Non-resident


Is this why Amherst Police Department has dragged its feet for 13 years now? Because UMass student Petrit Vasi was a non-resident? An immigrant? A refugee? From the Balkans? Was he Muslim, too?

A witness statement claims 5-6 cops were with Vasi when he was in front of Bart's, minutes before he was struck down and left for dead on Triangle Street. That's a lot of cops for one drunk student on a Thursday night.

Seems like Vasi took off down Kellogg Street. If so, why go in that direction, away from campus? Pretty unlikely he knew anyone on Kellogg, Smith, or Triangle Streets; not exactly a student kind of place. Was he fleeing from someone? Did someone try to catch up to him or chase him into the road? Did this person see Vasi get hit? Could he identify the car? The plate number? 

UMPD's cadet program (remember the UMPD cadet mentioned in the podcast?) was modeled on the Amherst Police Department's cadet program (since ended). Were one or two of these "cops" actually cadets? 

Once again, Amherst Police Department is fully aware of the sensational nature of the Maura Murray disappearance.


Amherst PD could easily issue a statement saying that there is no connection between the Vasi hit and Maura Murray's disappearance. Why hasn't Capt. Ronald Young, Capt. Jennifer Gundersen, or Chief Scott Livingstone done so? Other departments issue statements like this all the time. Unless there's some reason not to.

Saturday, November 5, 2016

Maura Murray's Missing Semester(s)

Maura Murray, according to many reports, graduated from high school in 2000, after which she entered the United States Military Academy - West Point - as a first-year student.

Which would have put her on track to graduate from USMA in the spring of 2004.

But at some point she apparently transferred from USMA to the University of Massachusetts.

However, she is consistently reported as having been a junior at the time of her disappearance in February 2004.


FROM UMASS DAILY COLLEGIAN 17 FEBRUARY 2004

Had she remained on track at West Point, February 2004 would have been her last semester there. Was she, when she vanished, a first-semester junior or a second-semester junior at UMass?

Did she take a year off? A semester off? Or did she have to repeat some time at UMass following her transfer? One semester or two? At UMass or another school? Was she ever a part-time, "night school" student somewhere?

Or did she take time off for some reason unrelated to her education?

Or was she in her final semester, soon to graduate, and various news reports kept getting it wrong?

Possibly related to this time-gap question is the You Tube video in which her father appears.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kM43tpDMrCg

At about the 00:50 mark, Maura's father says, "Things were... were really looking up for her."

I wonder what he meant. Was there a time when things were looking bleak? If so, is this related to the rarely or never-discussed missing semester(s)? And/or her ultimate fate?

This missing/repeated time during her years of higher education may not be a hugely important issue, but it seems to be one of several events oddly missing from the discussion of her disappearance. (Ditto the 12:07 to 12:14 phone call on Thursday night, for example; as mentioned here:

http://crypticcop.blogspot.com/2016/05/800-pm-to-1200-am-on-weekdays.html)


It might be helpful to know whether Maura's transfer from USMA was seamless or whether there was a break in time during which she was not a student at either USMA or UMass.

Or it might be totally irrelevant.

This omission is hard to understand. After all, it's a pretty simple, straightforward question. 

Why have no "citizen detectives" asked about this?